Why Did Dc Comics Decide To Kill Of Alfred​?

For many years, Alfred Pennyworth has been a crucial part of Batman's story as Bruce Wayne's butler, surrogate father, and best friend. Because of his enormous fan following throughout the course of his more than 80 years in comic book history, Alfred's passing in 2018 was tragic. Read the why did dc comics decide to kill of alfred?

The Bat-Man: First Knight #1 by Dan Jurgens, Mike Perkins, and Mike Spicer begins a three-part series that re-examines one of The Dark Knight's first murder investigations. A serial murderer who targets city leaders presents a new menace against the backdrop of a darker, more solemn Gotham City still dealing with the effects of World War I.

Drawing influence from Batman's early comic appearances, this Black Label volume offers a grim reimagining of his beginnings, including a poignant but subtly sad reason for Alfred's absence from the story as it develops.

Recommended to read: Superhero Black Hair Male Comic Characters

Bruce Wayne's life did not include Alfred in DC's new Batman: First Knight.There is a chance that

When Bruce, in his civilian guise, sees Commissioner Gordon being surrounded by media, he offers the commissioner a ride. Gordon is appreciative but surprised that Bruce drives himself, pointing out that people of Bruce's social standing usually have a chauffeur. "The family butler used to do the job, but he moved when I went to college," Bruce reveals in a nonchalant response. Since then, I haven't seen him. Despite its informal tone, this comment gives fans a lot of information with really depressing overtones.

Bruce's casual remark indicates two things: first, Alfred ceased being involved in Bruce's life once the latter enrolled in college. First of all, when Bruce was younger, Alfred departed and never came back, therefore the two were not close. Second, the dependable butler was absent when Bruce assumed the persona of Batman, thus he was never Bruce's primary confidant or ally. This revelation is especially devastating since it erases one of Batman's most significant and influential character connections by implying that the famous bond between Alfred Pennyworth and Bruce Wayne never existed in this realm.

Read Also: What Happened in My Adventures With Superman Season 2 Episode 8?

Although Bane's murder of Alfred was tragic, this new fate is perhaps more depressing.

In 2018's Batman #77, starring Tom King, Tony Daniel, and Mikel Janin, Alfred met his end. The creative team cannot be held solely responsible for this choice, which caused controversy among supporters. DC lobbied for it to be permanent, but Tom King disclosed that Alfred wasn't supposed to die; it was only supposed to be a fake-out. To illustrate the repercussions of disobeying Bane's authority in Gotham City, Bane assassinated the world's most beloved butler by snapping his neck in front of Damian Wayne. In the main continuity, Alfred Pennyworth is still dead as of 2024 (despite DC's propensity to bring figures back to life).

The tragedy of Alfred's passing in the City of Bane plot cannot be denied. But maybe even more terrible is his end in The Bat-Man: First Knight, which effectively erases a key member of the Bat-Family from history along with his cherished sarcasm and dry-witted humor. "It is better to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all," as Alfred Tennyson once said, is embodied in the difference between Alfred dying and never being a member of the Bat-Family. In other words, having Alfred and losing him was preferable than never having him at all.

Bruce Wayne cannot become the Batman we know without Alfred

Alfred Pennyworth is a recurring character in Bruce's life in almost all iterations of Batman, whether in television series, films, or comic books. He transcends both narratives and parallel realities. He provides crucial counsel, medical knowledge, manor maintenance, and tactical assistance, making him a pillar of Batman's cause. Alfred's emotional support, however, is just as important as his practical efforts since it gives Bruce a feeling of stability and humanity in the midst of the insanity of his quest. In the end, Alfred Pennyworth has had a major impact on Bruce's life, helping to shape Batman's identity, character growth, and lasting legacy as the Caped Crusader.

But Alfred's impact goes well beyond Bruce to include the latter's offspring, including Damian Wayne, Tim Drake, Cassandra Cain, Jason Todd, and Dick Grayson. These youthful vigilantes were greatly influenced by Alfred, who gave them the same steadfast support and direction that he gave Bruce. He had a significant effect on Damian in particular. By naming his cat after the butler, Damian showed his admiration and respect for Alfred, a gesture that says a lot about their bond. Damian remembers Alfred with nostalgia, even in Joshua Williamson's current Batman and Robin series, underscoring the lasting importance of Alfred's membership in the Bat-Family.

Reintroducing Alfred Pennyworth into Main Continuity is necessary.

The Bat-Man: First Knight is a moving reminder of Alfred's absence in the main continuity, even though it is not part of it. DC has a history of "killing off" characters only to subsequently show that they never killed or bring them back in surprising ways, as was previously established. Characters like Jason Todd, Superman, Damian Wayne, and several more are notable examples. But the more the years go by and Alfred is still dead, the less likely it is that he will come back.

Must Know: Kara Zor El My Adventures With Superman: Kara Zor El

FAQs: Why Did Dc Comics Decide To Kill Of Alfred

Why did DC kill off Alfred?

DC lobbied for it to be permanent, but Tom King disclosed that Alfred wasn't supposed to die; it was only supposed to be a fake-out. To illustrate the repercussions of disobeying Bane's authority in Gotham City, Bane assassinated the world's most beloved butler by snapping his neck in front of Damian Wayne and why did dc comics decide to kill of alfred.

How did Batman react to Alfred's death?

He believed that Batman would finally be broken if he killed Alfred. It didn't, of course. Batman was more enraged than ever, and this rage strengthened his resolve. After Batman iciously battered Bane for this crime, he planned to kill Thomas Wayne next.

What makes Alfred such a Batman devotee?

Reluctantly, Alfred helped the young orphan in his quest to become Batman after raising him. He is Batman's most devoted ally because to his diverse skill set, which includes everything from cooking to medical, as well as his formal manner, which grounds the Dark Knight and diverts anybody who might otherwise question Batman's actual identity.

Has Batman ever been deceived by Alfred?

Alfred betrayed Bruce by rigging the Batcave and his cars to murder him after realizing how corrupted Bruce had become. Bruce, however, used the façade to lower Alfred's defenses long enough to overcome him when Alfred had the chance to murder him. Bruce persuaded Alfred that there was still good in him.

What makes Batman not want to kill?

Batman's "no killing" rule is meant to make sure that he never lets himself get so far ahead of the law that the last check on his behavior is lifted and that he always acts in the sake of justice rather than retaliation.

Superman prevented Batman from murdering the Joker, but why?

Before Superman showed there, Batman was more than eager to murder the Joker. In a bizarre change of events, it turns out that the Joker had gained diplomatic immunity and was now the diplomat to Iran. If Batman did anything to him, it might spark a global crisis, which Superman vows to stop at nothing.

Why does Batman always defeat Superman?

Batman has an advantage over Superman in combat because of his backup plans and access to Kryptonite. Batman's relationship with Superman is demonstrated by the fact that he uses a Kryptonite dart to disable Superman when needed and breaches his own rule to save him.